My partner and I have very different preferences when it comes to music in bed. I usually prefer silence, but sporadically also enjoy relaxing classical music.
My partner, on the other hand, loves drifting off to the soft tones of a Spanish talk radio program.
Neither of us wants to listen to the other’s choice, and we prefer not to wear headphones unless we’re trying to block out noise from neighbors.
The solution? Little pillow speakers that allow us to listen to our chosen music or radio in private. We’ve tested a good range in recent months, and I’ll be talking about the best we’ve found in this review.
So if you also need a discreet way to listen to music, radio or even ocean sounds in bed, you’ll find some inexpensive pillow speakers below that have just enough volume to reach your ears.
To avoid repeating the same information, all of these speakers will connect with a standard 3.5 mm headphone jack. So they are compatible with most audio devices, except some iPhones which will need the lightning adaptor.
1. C. Crane Soft Speaker 3
The best pillow speaker overall, with a soft casing and volume boosting Amp
The Soft Speaker 3 from C. Crane is currently my favorite pillow speaker. What makes it stand out is that the manufacturer has clearly thought about what people might need in a pillow speaker, and tried to make it work while keeping the cost reasonable.
I love that it has a removable soft casing for the speaker to hide inside. It means you don’t have to bury the speaker under your pillow as you do with most others; instead, you can place it under or next to your ear, which is great if you have a thick pillow or your hearing isn’t the best.
It also has a useful control box built into the very long cable (78 inches long). The control lets you select the Amp, which boosts the volume nicely.
There are sleep timers of 1, 4 or 8 hours, which is great for saving the battery or if you just want music for the start of the night. And you can switch between voice or music modes, depending on what you’re listening to.
My only criticism is that you need 2 x AAA batteries if you want to use the Amp. You can ignore that though, and just play it on normal volumes without the batteries.
It’s the sound quality that also makes this one a winner for me. Many pillow speakers really struggle when music has bass, or are so quiet that you can’t even hear them through a standard pillow. But this one both sounds clear and is audible through all but the very thickest of pillows.
2. Sangean Pillow Speaker PS-300
A compact pillow speaker with in-line volume control
The Sangean PS-300 pillow speaker is a versatile little pillow speaker which shares some similarities with the C. Crane. Again, it consists of one small and unobtrusive speaker and also has an in-line volume control.
A key difference is that it’s not designed to be placed directly under your ear since it has no padding or material casing. Instead, you can place it under your pillow, inside your pillowcase, or next to your ear if you prefer.
It also has an additional Amp which boosts the volume. The Amp requires just one AAA battery, but you can use it without the Amp if you want to. I find the boosted volume is really useful for podcasts, radio and audiobooks.
However, if you listen to music that has a lot of bass, the sound does seem to distort if you turn the Amp on and the volume up. That said, it’s still a great option if you listen to spoken word or relaxing music.
I can hear both speaking and music easily played under thin and medium sized pillows. But if you have a dense pillow and/or struggle with your hearing, then you might find you need to put the speaker inside the top of the pillow case instead.
The cable is 47 inches long. While that’s not as long as the C. Crane, it’s still more than long enough the reach a nightstand, even if it’s far from the bed.
A flat speaker that sits under your pillow
The PillowSonic is essentially a long rectangular insert that you can slide under any pillow. It contains 2 flat, digital micro-speakers, encased in a thin foam so you won’t feel them through the pillow.
The fact that it has 2 speakers means you have stereo sound, so it’s intended to provide more of the modern feel you’re probably used to when listening to music.
But in my experience, it doesn’t really sound any different than the previous two speakers once you have a pillow on top of it. Perhaps in part because the speakers are actually quite close together – the overall design isn’t as long as it seems to look in photos.
The sound quality is reasonable, especially if you use a thinner pillow. But it’s lacking an Amp and the overall volume isn’t as loud as the C.Crane or Sangean without that boost. It does have an inline volume control though, so it’s easy to adjust the volume in the night with your eyes still closed.
The cable is long enough to stretch to a bedside table, and comes with an extension. I like that as it means you don’t have to tie up excess cable if your audio device is really close to your pillow.
I found this one is good enough for voice and quiet music, though also struggles a bit with electronic music that has a lot of bass. And if you use a very thick pillow, like all the other pillow speakers, there will be heavy muffling.
4. C.Crane Soft Speaker 2
A simpler version of the Soft Speaker with just an in-line volume
For the final pillow speaker in my list, it’s back to the reliable C. Crane series. This time it’s the Soft Speaker version 2, which was my top pick until version 3 came along.
The main differences are that the casing is smaller, so it’s a little less padding under your ear. And there is no Amp control box, so it’s missing all of those features that the version 3 offers.
What it does have though is a very simple design. So it’s perhaps better if you just want to plug your pillow speaker into your audio device and never have to worry about batteries or finding the right button on the control unit.
It has a simple slider inline volume control on the cable. That means you can easily change the volume in the night without opening your eyes and blinding yourself when your smartphone screen fires up.
The cable is the same length as version 3, at a whopping 78 inches long. This is useful if you have a radio on a desk or shelf; otherwise, it’s a lot of cable you’ll want to tie up neatly.
The sound quality is nice enough to listen to people talking or soft music. But it’s definitely quieter than both version 3 and the Sangean, and similar to the Pillowsonic.
I don’t think it’s ideal for thicker pillows because of that and is best used under the ear. But if you use a thin or medium sized pillow and your hearing is ok, you can pop it under your pillow no problem