The 10 Most Comfortable Mattress Toppers

Disclosure: My website is reader supported. If you choose to buy a product after clicking a link, I may earn a commission, at no extra cost to you. Learn more.

Using a comfortable mattress topper is a practical and affordable way to enhance your bed, providing a significant improvement without the expense of replacing your entire mattress.

Whether you’re looking to rejuvenate an old mattress, adjust its firmness, enhance breathability, or add targeted support for your back or pressure points, there’s a topper out there for you.

Selecting the ideal topper is as personal as choosing a new mattress. So in this article, I’ll be recommending a diverse range of mattress toppers that have the potential to improve the overall feel of your bed, and hopefully your sleep along with it.

As well as covering different styles and materials, I’ve also included a range to suit all budgets, with both low-cost and luxury options.

Contents

• Overview of the mattress toppers
• The materials used in mattress toppers
• The mattress toppers in detail
• Comparison tables

Overview of the mattress toppers

---

---

---

---

---

---

---

---

---

The materials used in mattress toppers

If you’re not sure which style of mattress topper might suit you best, here are some of the key benefits and downsides of the different materials to keep in mind when choosing one:

Memory foam

• Support and pressure relief: Memory foam contours to your body, providing excellent support and relieving pressure points.
• Versatile comfort: Suitable and comfortable for all sleeping positions.
• Density: Lower density offers a softening effect, while higher density increases firmness.
• Motion isolation: Minimizes disturbances from partner movements, ensuring uninterrupted sleep.
• Considerations: Heat retention is a potential downside, and the weight of the topper should be considered if mobility is a concern.

Latex

• Breathability: Latex is the most breathable material, making it ideal for hot sleepers.
• Support and responsiveness: Provides excellent support and contouring while offering a more bouncy and responsive feel compared to memory foam.
• Versatile comfort: Suitable for all sleeping positions.
• Softness or firmness options: Latex toppers can add softness or firmness to your bed, depending on your preference.
• Durability: Known for its longevity, latex toppers can last 10 to 20 years.
• Natural antimicrobial and hypoallergenic properties: Latex is naturally antimicrobial, hypoallergenic, and resistant to dust mites.
• Considerations: It may not be suitable for cold sleepers in winter months.

Synthetic (fiberfill, microfiber, hollow fiber)

• Affordability: Synthetic/fiber-fill toppers are typically more budget-friendly compared to latex, memory foam, wool, or down.
• Comfort and softness: Adds extra comfort and softness, often providing a plush “sleeping on a cloud” sensation.
• Warmth: May provide warmth, making it suitable for cold sleepers.
• Lightweight and portable: Easy to move from room to room or machine wash (if it’s machine washable).
• Considerations: May require occasional fluffing as it flattens, and can retain heat.

Wool

• Temperature regulation: Provides good temperature regulation throughout all seasons.
• Plush comfort: Adds a feeling of plushness without compromising support.
• Breathability and moisture-wicking: Promotes breathability and effectively wicks away moisture for a dry and comfortable sleep.
• Hypoallergenic and dust mite resistant: Naturally hypoallergenic and more resistant to dust mites compared to synthetic materials.
• Versatile for back and front sleepers: Suitable for back and front sleepers, offering good body support.
• Considerations: Higher price point, and periodic fluffing to reduce flattening.

Feather/down

• Plush and soft comfort: Feather and down toppers provide a plush and soft sleep surface, with a fluffy feel.
• Temperature regulation: Effective temperature regulation, providing warmth for those who sleep cold and preventing overheating during the summer.
• Versatile for all sleeping positions: Suitable and comfortable for any sleeping position.
• Natural and Hypoallergenic: Feather and down materials are naturally hypoallergenic, making them suitable for people with allergies.
• Considerations: Periodic shaking required to maintain loft, and ethical concerns regarding animal welfare.

The mattress toppers in detail

1. Sleep Innovations 4 inch Dual Layer Memory Foam Mattress Topper

Two layers of memory foam and plush fiberfill combine to provide softness and cushioning for your body

The Sleep Innovations dual-layer mattress topper is a good choice if you want to soften your bed while maintaining effective body support. It’s the most comfortable, budget-friendly combined memory foam and pillow top mattress topper I’ve tried, so I decided to discuss it first for those on a tighter budget.

Unlike a standard four inch topper, it has two separate layers designed to work together. There are three versions: plush support with extra memory foam, enhanced support with an even split of memory foam and pillow top, and cooling support with a more breathable top layer. I bought the enhanced support, so I’ll focus on that one.

The bottom layer has two inches of medium density memory foam that conforms to your body shape, cushioning pressure points. The top layer, also two inches thick, is filled with plush fiber fill separated into boxed sections. It feels like a soft pillow, providing additional padding. The top cover stretches tightly over the foam section and mattress, keeping both layers in place, and is machine washable.

I found the two layers combined excellently to cushion the body. It may not suit those preferring a very firm surface, but it will appeal if you like a soft or medium-soft surface. It also has good motion isolation, minimizing partner disturbances when changing positions.

The dual-layer design allows experimentation with just the memory foam or fiberfill layer, or combining them for maximum comfort. The combined four inches significantly alters your current mattress feel, effectively softening a firm mattress. The materials are CertiPUR-US certified, meaning they are made without harmful chemicals.

My main criticism is the gel cooling concept. While it might be better than some memory foam toppers in terms of heat retention, it still feels relatively warm. If you’re a naturally hot sleeper, a latex mattress topper might suit you better.

Overall, the Sleep Innovations mattress topper does its main job of adding extra cushioning to an existing mattress very effectively. Its high ranking on my list reflects the excellent price-quality balance.

All five sizes usually range between $110 and $160, depending on the season. You’ll have 30 days to test it out and a reassuring 10 year warranty. So if your preference is for a softer surface to sink into at night, it’s a great choice for a reasonable price.

---

2. Pure Green Latex Mattress Topper

The best latex mattress topper overall, perfect for hot sleepers and at an affordable price

The Pure Green latex mattress topper is my top pick of the latex toppers due to its balance between price and quality. It’s more affordable than some luxury brands but equally comfortable, breathable, and durable.

For instance, the two inch queen size costs $200, or $265 with a cotton cover. This is significantly less expensive than the two inch Saatva at $445 and the two inch Plush Beds at $449. Although the company is based in Chicago, the latex is harvested in Sri Lanka, possibly accounting for the lower price compared to American-sourced latex toppers.

The topper is made from 100% natural latex, free of synthetic materials, and holds GOLS Certified Organic, Oeko-Tex Standard 100, and Greenguard Gold certifications. This ensures not only longevity but also a breathable sleep surface that won’t feel as warm as memory foam.

If you’ve never experienced a latex topper, it does feel different to memory foam. To me, it’s the springiness that’s most noticeable. It conforms to your body like memory foam, but it feels like you’re cushioned more on top rather than sinking in.

It’s available in three firmness levels – soft, medium, and firm. I bought the medium firmness version, which was very comfortable, supporting my hips, back, and shoulders well and keeping my spine aligned during the night.

In terms of thickness, one inch may be too little unless your mattress is already comfortable, and you just want a bit more support. Two inches should suit most people, but three inches might be better for very heavy people or those with significant pressure point issues. I had the two inch king size and found it ideal for my somewhat heavier body (188 lb / 85kg) and tendency to sleep on my side.

If I had to pinpoint a minor drawback, the cover appears more basic compared to the Saatva or PlushBeds covers. However, once you put your own bedsheet on, it’s not an issue at all. The quality of the latex topper itself, which is much more important, didn’t disappoint.

In summary, the Pure Green latex mattress topper offers an excellent balance between quality and cost. It provides a temperature-neutral sleeping surface with thickness and firmness options to tweak or significantly change the feel of your mattress. It’s one of the most comfortable and breathable mattress toppers I’ve ever slept on, so I highly recommend it, especially if you’re a hot sleeper.

---

3. ViscoSoft High Density Memory Foam Mattress Topper

The most comfortable memory foam mattress topper overall, with excellent cushioning and a convenient cover design

The ViscoSoft memory foam mattress topper strikes the right balance between comfort, support, breathability, and price. It also has one of the best covers I’ve seen in any mattress topper, clearly designed with both practicality and comfort in mind.

A key feature is its high-density memory foam, which offers exceptional support to pressure points – a crucial factor for anyone dealing with body aches. The company describes the firmness level as medium, which I’d agree with. However, the foam is soft enough to cushion the body well in any sleeping position.

I found it especially comfortable on my side compared to firmer or less padded toppers. It also worked really well on my front or back, contouring to my body and keeping my back aligned.

Though memory foam typically traps body heat, the ViscoSoft felt more breathable than basic memory foam options I’ve tried, making it suitable for hot sleepers who enjoy memory foam cushioning.

The durability of the ViscoSoft is another important feature. The high-density foam helps it resist sagging or flattening, demonstrating long-lasting structural integrity. This means it’s not just a short-term investment for a good night’s sleep but a long-term one.

The design of the cover particularly impressed me, which was clearly made with the user in mind. It’s removable and machine-washable, has a slip-resistant mesh underside, and straps to secure it to your mattress. These convenient details also make it a solid option for boosting comfort on an airbed for short-term stays.

One downside is the limited availability of sizes and thicknesses compared to some other toppers. A couple of sizes are often only available in one of the two or three inch thicknesses, not both.

The price, ranging from $159 to $199, is higher than the LinenSpa but considerably lower than the Layla (see below). Personally, I think the quality of the foam, cover, breathability, and support make this topper very good value for money.

Overall, the ViscoSoft is an excellent choice if you’d like a comfortable, high-quality memory foam topper. It provides effective support, cushions the body well, and feels more breathable than basic memory foam.

---

4. Linenspa Memory Foam Mattress Topper

An affordable memory foam mattress topper that will soften your bed and cushion your body

The Linenspa is the most comfortable low-cost memory foam mattress topper I’ve tried, and a great choice if you’d like to soften your existing mattress.

Even though the other memory foam toppers I cover in this article have the edge design-wise, this one provides an opportunity to enjoy the cushioning of memory foam for a lower price.

Despite its affordability, it doesn’t skimp on quality or comfort, so it will suit those looking to improve their sleep quality without overspending.

You have the option to select either a two or three inch thickness. Although it comes at a higher cost, I would recommend the three inch option if you need maximum body cushioning. The topper has a soft feel but adapts excellently to your body contour, providing consistent support from head to toe.

The cushioning of the memory foam means you’ll hopefully be able to drift off to sleep with less bother from pressure points. If you have an old mattress that’s become uncomfortable, it will help hide lumpy parts and reduce the firmness a notch or two.

For such a reasonable price, it’s hard to complain about the Linenspa mattress topper. Even the three inch thickness mattress sizes cost between $60 and $120, which is significantly less expensive than some of the others in this review.

The foam has earned the CertiPUR-US certification, which is a reassuring sign of quality. Additionally, it comes with a three year warranty, which is a good length of time for a memory foam topper.

The main potential downside to consider is that it feels quite warm to sleep on, especially in the summer or if you’re a naturally hot sleeper.

They have tried to mitigate the heat buildup with the gel infused design and the open cell structure, but it will still feel warmer than a latex or wool mattress topper. If you like sleeping on a warm surface, that won’t be an issue; if you’re a hot sleeper, it might be though.

Overall, if your goal is to add some extra cushioning and comfort to your mattress, along with support for pressure points in areas like the hips and shoulders, you will get that with the Linenspa, and for a very reasonable price.

---

5. Saatva Latex Mattress Topper

A springy and breathable luxury topper with an organic cotton cover that will suit hot sleepers

The Saatva was the first latex mattress topper I bought when I moved to the United States. It had just the right balance of support and comfort, and it was still going strong after three years before I started testing other mattress toppers.

The Saatva is made with a medium level of firmness and feels very comfortable and springy to lie on, whether that’s on your back, front, or side.

I naturally sleep a lot on my side, so I need good support for my hips and shoulders in particular, which are the first to complain if the bed feels too firm. I found that it provides excellent cushioning and support in all the key pressure point areas such as the hips, shoulders, and back.

As a hot sleeper, I was impressed by the Saatva’s low heat retention compared to the many memory foam toppers I’ve tried.

The included organic cotton cover also adds a touch of style. It feels soft and has convenient corner straps to secure the topper to your mattress. While the cover gives a luxurious look and feel, I’m not sure it justifies the higher price alone though.

I also like that the Saatva is made in the U.S. by a responsible company that supports its local community. The latex is eco-INSTITUT® and Forest Stewardship Council (FSC) certified, meaning it’s pollutant and emission-free, with no off-gassing.

The main downside is that the 1.5 inch thickness might not support heavier bodies. If you are heavier, the Pure Green or Plush Beds offer more thickness choices.

My other caveat is that it’s considerably more expensive than the budget-friendly toppers in this review. As always, the price will depend on the size of your bed, with a range from $325 to $565.

Saatva offers a generous 180 night trial with a money-back guarantee, one of the longest trial periods I’ve encountered – especially compared to Plush Beds, who don’t offer refunds for toppers.

On balance, if you’d like to upgrade your bed with a comfortable, breathable sleep surface, the Saatva is my top luxury latex topper recommendation. It’s an impressive mattress topper that’s well-constructed, finished to a high standard, and provides effective body support.

---

6. Parachute Down Alternative Mattress Topper

The best down alternative mattress topper, with a thick layer of plush padding to sink into

The Parachute down alternative mattress topper is a great choice if you’re looking for a cozy and plush sleeping experience. In some ways, it’s like the top layer of the Sleep Innovations, but with significantly more padding and a more luxurious feel.

The topper has a thickness of three inches and features a dual-chamber design, which includes two layers of plush microfiber that provide snug and enveloping comfort. Additionally, it uses a special three-dimensional baffle box stitching, which helps in keeping the fill evenly distributed across the entire surface.

The fill itself is made of a hypoallergenic microfiber designed to mimic the warmth and fluffiness of real down. It creates a soft yet supportive surface suitable for all sleepers, no matter their preferred sleeping position. Personally, I found this topper to be incredibly comfortable and slept really well on it.

A soft 100% cotton sateen shell finishes the topper, adding an extra layer of luxury. Despite being warmer than latex or wool, it does feel more breathable than the Sleep Innovations. So if you tend to sleep hot but still desire the coziness of a down-like topper, it’s one to consider.

One potential downside is the lack of straps to secure it to the mattress. While this didn’t pose a problem for me, it could be an issue for more restless sleepers or those who prefer not to have to reposition their bedding regularly.

While the price ranges from $199 to $299, depending on the size, Parachute offers a 60 day trial period. This gives you ample time to discover if you’ll sleep well on it.

All in all, the Parachute Down alternative mattress topper provides a luxurious feel and supportive sleep surface, making it a great option for those after a cozy down alternative.

While it comes at a higher price point than other fiberfill toppers, the hypoallergenic microfiber filling, baffle box construction, cotton sateen shell, and 60 day trial period make it one I recommend trying.

---

7. Sleep & Beyond Wool Mattress Topper

A topper that gets the right balance of comfort and temperature regulation with a wool fill

If you’re not a fan of synthetic materials like memory foam or polyester and you’d like a temperature-neutral surface that’s comfortable all year round, the Sleep & Beyond wool mattress topper is one to have on your radar.

It comes encased in 270 thread count natural cotton percale and is filled with 100% British Shropshire wool, with no other artificial filler. It feels durable with its strong stitching, and as wool toppers typically have a long lifespan, it should last for many years with proper care.

With a thickness of 1.5 inches, it adds a layer of plush comfort to your mattress that I found to be of medium firmness. It doesn’t give you a ‘sinking in’ feeling like memory foam does; instead, it feels more like extra padding rather than body contouring.

I found it to be very comfortable when lying on my back or front. However, it wasn’t the best fit for me as I often sleep on my side and missed the additional support that latex or memory foam provides.

One major advantage I found with the wool topper is the lack of heat buildup underneath me during the summer months. It felt much cooler compared to memory foam. However, it was also snug and cozy in the winter, making it suitable for places with extreme temperature variations, like New York where I tested mine.

Although the 1.5 inch thickness adds some comfortable padding and support, it won’t completely mask a significantly lumpy mattress. But a wool mattress topper of this size is still a good choice if you’re looking for some additional body support and comfort without the feeling of being stuck in one position due to excessive sinking.

Be aware that the wool will compact over time, so you’ll need to fluff it occasionally. This may require some effort, especially if you don’t have the strength to lift it yourself. However, a plus is that you can machine wash the entire topper instead of just removing a cover or spot cleaning.

At $249 for the twin, it’s one of the pricier twin size toppers I’ve come across. However, the California king size is $329, so the price doesn’t rise as steeply for larger sizes when compared to some other toppers.

In summary, the Sleep & Beyond topper is a great choice for those who prefer a comfortable, temperature-neutral surface and want to avoid synthetic materials.

---

8. Exceptional Sheets Down Alternative Mattress Pad

A low-cost way to soften your mattress with a fluffy feel

The Exceptional Sheets down alternative mattress pad, while technically advertised as a pad rather than a topper, can serve a similar purpose, ultimately adding to the comfort of your bed.

Filled with Revoloft cluster fiber, the pad offers a soft and comfortable surface that works well as an alternative to goose or duck down. Although it doesn’t replicate the exact feel of down, it provides a cozy sleeping surface without the risk of rogue feathers poking through the cover.

While it doesn’t offer the same level of support as a memory foam or latex topper, I found that it does a pretty good job due to the soft padding you’ll sink into. Additionally, the silky bamboo blend cover enhances the softness, and the design, featuring individual boxes of fiber, helps maintain an even shape.

However, if your current mattress has significant lumps or dips, you’ll likely need a thicker topper than this one, such as the Parachute. It can mask minor signs of wear, but it won’t be effective if the mattress is in particularly bad shape.

On the plus side, it’s easy to clean, being machine washable, and its lightweight nature makes it easier to maneuver than some bulkier toppers if you need to move it to a different bed.

With prices ranging from $57 for a twin to $79 for a king, it’s a very affordable option compared to memory foam, latex, or wool. Plus, you have 30 days to determine if it sufficiently increases your bed’s comfort or to return it if you feel you need a more substantial topper.

On balance, if you’re looking to add a touch of additional softness and comfort on a tight budget, the Exceptional Sheets pad is worth considering. It can be used on top of a mattress or even a firmer topper, like memory foam or latex, and should make your current mattress feel noticeably softer.

However, be aware that it won’t provide significant support for your body or pressure points and might not suit heavier body sizes as well as some of the other mattress toppers in this article.

---

9. Layla Memory Foam Mattress Topper

A soft, copper gel infused memory foam mattress topper that cushions the body well

The Layla mattress topper doesn’t just look stylish with its hexagonal patterned cover; it also delivers that much-desired ‘sleeping on a cloud’ sensation. It has a soft feel, yet still provides excellent cushioning and support for pressure points, making it a very comfortable surface to lie on.

As a side sleeper, I found it relieved pressure on my hips and shoulders, my typical problem areas. When lying on my back, it cushioned my body well, preventing any lower back soreness. On my front, it prevented excessive sinking or back arching as it conformed to my body rather than creating a dip.

It also has excellent motion isolation, which will help ensure two people can sleep undisturbed, especially if your existing mattress already has reasonable motion isolation.

The memory foam includes copper-infused gel, improving breathability and reducing bacteria growth. Although its impact is hard to quantify compared to the general foam design, it certainly doesn’t overheat like basic, dense memory foam. While it isn’t as cool as the latex toppers in this article, if you’ve used memory foam before, you may find this one to be more breathable.

The main downside is the absence of a firm version, making it unsuitable if you prefer a firm sleep surface. Also, if you’re a particularly hot sleeper or have a warm bedroom, memory foam, despite its comparative breathability, might not be the best choice.

Price-wise, it’s at the higher end, ranging from $289 – $489, depending on size and Layla’s regular sales. The copper-infused gel, cover, and quality materials justify the price compared to basic memory foam brands. Additionally, they offer a reliable 30 night money-back trial and a five year warranty.

In summary, the Layla mattress topper, with its copper-infused gel, is a high-quality product offering a good balance of comfort, support, and breathability. While it may not suit those looking for a firm surface, hot sleepers, or those on a tight budget, it’s a good choice if you’d like a premium memory foam topper with effective body cushioning and a stylish design.

---

10. Plush Beds Latex Mattress Topper

A 100% natural latex topper that supports the body well, with a wide range of firmness options

The Plush Beds latex mattress topper was a lifesaver during New York’s sweltering summers, providing a cool and comfortable sleep surface to relax on. In my experience, there are three key positives about Plush Beds and their topper, and a potential deal-breaker to understand.

First, they appear to have good production standards, evidenced by their OEKO-TEX Standard 100 and Greenguard Gold certifications. They produce 100% natural latex mattress toppers in the US from sustainably farmed materials.

Second, the range of options is impressive. Five firmness options and two thicknesses provide flexibility to find the perfect combination for your sleep preferences. It’s unusual for a latex topper to be available in so many firmness levels, including extra-firm, making Plush Beds unique in that respect.

I chose the three inch, medium firmness because I’m heavier and needed the extra support. It supported my hips and shoulders well, providing excellent cushioning and making it comfortable to sleep in any position.

Third, the topper is well-made and robust, designed to last up to 20 years, according to the company.

The main drawback is the no-returns policy for mattress toppers, even though you can return their mattresses. If you haven’t tried latex before and are unsure if it’s right for you, I’d recommend the Pure Green or Saatva, as both can be returned if you’re not happy with them.

Another consideration is cost, ranging from $288 – $974, depending on bed size, thickness, and firmness. A firm, three inch, California king with a cover is significantly more expensive than the Pure Green and even the Saatva. However, the durability of latex, which doesn’t lose form or flatten as quickly as other mattress toppers, offers good value in the long run.

As for the craftsmanship, I have no complaints though. The topper provides excellent body support, and I’ve enjoyed many good nights’ sleep on it. Compared to memory foam toppers, which also offer great pressure point support, I prefer the springy feel of latex. It cushions my body well while feeling cooler.

On balance, I was a fan of the Plush Beds latex mattress topper for its breathability and comfort. You can use it to adjust the softness or firmness of your existing mattress, and it shouldn’t need replacing for many years.

Comparison tables

In the table below, you can compare the materials and prices for a queen size mattress topper on the day I last updated this article (September 1, 2023). Please note that they may fluctuate over time, so this is just to give you an idea of the price range for different brands, materials, and thickness options.

You can also see which ones are likely to feel warmer, cooler, or neutral in temperature.

The blue links will take you either to Amazon or the company websites. For those with multiple examples, I’ve only included one link to avoid repetition, but you can find the other sizes through that one.

Mattress Topper	Material	Feels	Price
Sleep Innovations	Memory foam and fiberfill	Warm	$139.99
Pure Green 1 inch (Med)	Latex	Cool	$155
Pure Green 2 inch	Latex	Cool	$200
Pure Green 3 inch	Latex	Cool	$275
ViscoSoft	Memory foam	Warm	$169.95
Linenspa 2 inch	Memory foam	Warm	$59.99
Linenspa 3 inch	Memory foam	Warm	$89.99
Saatva	Latex	Cool	$445
Parachute	Down alternative	Warm	$259
Sleep & Beyond	Wool	Neutral	$299
Exceptional Sheets	Revoloft Fiberfill	Warm	$99.99
Layla	Memory foam	Warm	$249
Plush Beds 2 Inch (med)	Latex	Cool	$311
Plush Beds 3 Inch (med)	Latex	Cool	$449

In the next table, you can compare which mattress sizes, thickness options, and firmness options each topper is available in.

Mattress Topper	Bed Sizes	Thickness Options (Inches)	Firmness options
Sleep Innovations	Twin Full Queen King Cal king	4″	Med-soft
Pure Green	Twin Twin XL Full Queen King Cal King	1″ 2″ 3″	Soft Medium Firm
ViscoSoft	Twin XL Short queen King Cal king.	2″ 3″	Medium
Linenspa	Small single Twin Twin XL Full Full XL Queen Short queen King Cal King	2″ 3″	Soft
Saatva	Twin Twin XL Full Queen King Cal King Split king	1.5″	Medium
Parachute	Twin Twin XL Full Queen King Cal King	3″	Soft
Sleep & Beyond	Twin Twin XL Full Queen King Cal King Crib	1.5″	Medium
Exceptional sheets	Twin Twin XL Full Queen King Cal King	1.5″	Soft
Layla	Twin Twin XL Full Queen King Cal King	2″	Med-soft
Plush Beds	Twin Twin XL Full Queen King Cal King	2″ 3″	Soft Med-soft Medium Med-firm Extra-firm

This is a long article to scroll through, so here are some links to jump back to previous sections in case you’d like to read them again:

• Overview of the mattress toppers
• Which material to choose?
• The mattress toppers in detail
• Comparison tables

---

You might also like

If you’re still unsure which style of mattress topper would suit you best, you might find it helpful to read my guide to choosing a mattress topper.